So, So many variables
I have seen housings in both directions.
Brand new replacement housing , identical shim. Brand new housing, not even close.
In my past life, I changed more housings than gears .
Production ring and pinions , all over .
Later OE stuff yes much closer, hence guys using original pinion shim, calling it a day, and getting away with it,,,,, usually!
Anything ring and pinion is going to change shim stacks.
Now throw in the adapter bearing used to fit the aftermarket posi units in the small 8.5.
GM never even used that bearing in production.
I also don't think manufacturers hold call out or tolerance as tight when they know there is an adjustment provision .
While the total L+R carrier total "usually" falls into similar , ( .24 something x 2 comes to mind ) this aftermarket spool is like .100 wide .
Side shim total governed by housing, bearings, posi.
Actual numbers , add gears, pinion bearings choice of depth, choice of lash, choice of preload.
Yeah in theroy if every design call out was bang on , every manufacturer agreed to and adhered to ,,,,,,, but come on, not in this world!!