Although this thread is dated a bit, for completeness, I'll add some thoughts for those chasing problems. Aluminum will conduct electrical current just fine. However, aluminum has some serious shortcomings in the electrical design trade.
First ... aluminum oxidizes in air, the oxide is almost "glass" like. It will actually create an insulation layer on top of the aluminum. It is important when using aluminum for electrical circuits to use emory cloth to remove the oxide and then coat the cleaned surface with an inhibitor to keep the oxide from reforming (like "Noalox").
Second ... aluminum is soft and will move (flow). This makes it marginal for electrical connections as it will move away from a tight connection. Not good. These aluminum threaded inserts will likely loosen over time. The threaded hole will be fine, but the aluminum to steel crimp will loosen. You won't necessarily notice this flow, but it will happen. So? Well, as it loosens, air will get in and oxidize the aluminum to steel connection and you will be back where you started ... except, it will look fine.
To be fair, this will take some time, but as our cars are in the elements, less than you think.
Star washers are actually very effective ... the star digs into the fender steel and makes good contact and keeps the air out at that contact point. It can rust all over and still keep an airtight connection under it's fangs. Ever take off a star washer and it looks like crap except exactly where the little points touch the steel? Yep.
I highly recommend avoiding aluminum in electrical connections in our cars due to the elements we live in. Copper does not have the same problems to any measureable degree.
Good luck.