The wood grain will never match the original.... Try to get the ins company to re-wood the whole side of the car, or find a old fender with wood grain......
If it was the other's guy fault, then his insurance company is responsible to fix it (or pay you for it). Even if they take care of getting the car fixed except for the trim, they owe something for the replacement trim. Get a quote for the used trim and then find out how much shop time is to be quoted for removing and replacing it times the shop labor rate. They can cut you a check for it. Get the trim and make your own deal with the shop to install it (or do it yourself).The insurance only gave me two options, take the check and run or they will do everything but the trim. If I took the check the money would be spent somewhere else and I don't want to drive a dented p.o.s. again.
If it was the other's guy fault, then his insurance company is responsible to fix it (or pay you for it). Even if they take care of getting the car fixed except for the trim, they owe something for the replacement trim. Get a quote for the used trim and then find out how much shop time is to be quoted for removing and replacing it times the shop labor rate. They can cut you a check for it. Get the trim and make your own deal with the shop to install it (or do it yourself).
While your insurance may not like it, if you have uninsured/underinsured and comprehensive coverage then they are on the hook for everything. At least try to get them to give you credit for the trim towards your deductable.The guy took off when I called the cops. I got his plate and with the help of a friend at the dmv got all the info about him. Last I heard, no one has gotten a hold of him yet. Until I hear different, I'm on my own for the trim.
While your insurance may not like it, if you have uninsured/underinsured and comprehensive coverage then they are on the hook for everything. At least try to get them to give you credit for the trim towards your deductable.