I'm willing to pay more for better quality. I hate rework. I would be happy with the $87 plastic one, but I have tried them in the past on other cars and wound up replacing them shortly after install. That is why I wanted to find out about the Cold Case. I hate to be the guinea pig, and $360 is about the most I'm willing to spend, but if it lasts 22 years like the OEM I would be happy.