I've run 225/70-15, stock 255/50-17, 285/40-17 on the stock wheels, and the same 285/40-17 on 10" wide wheels (measured section width got 3/4" wider when mounted on 10" wheels). There was a noticeable difference in handling between all of them that improved in the order listed. Given the option of purchasing what you want (i.e. wallet doesn't have you cruising used tire ads) I would go with a matched set of 285/40 and 255/45. They're both 26" in diameter (1" smaller than stock), will give you a narrower tire in the front vs. the rear, and will only marginally affect your speedometer. Reprogram if that's a sticking point for you. I wouldn't spend any amount on 235/55's, but that's me.
Why do you want a narrower tire up front? Appearance? 285/40 and 255/45 will give you more of the Big-n-Little look if that's what you're after. Have a wandering/tracking issue with current tires? Get away from the BFG's and that will likely go away provided your front end is in good shape. I had three different pairs of BFG's on the front of my SS and it tracked like mad until I finally gave up and switched brands. Performance in ALL categories went up and the tracking went away.